Emissions Trading Scheme 'Corporate Welfare'
Byron Clark , Christchurch: Oct 1 2008
Made Popular Oct 1 2008
New Zealand :

Emissions Trading Scheme 'Corporate Welfare'

Information obtained by the No Right Turn blog under the Official Information Act has shown New Zealand’s new Emissions Trading Scheme, passed to help New Zealand meet its commitments under the Kyoto Protocol, to be a corporate welfare scheme, “rather than a pollution reduction scheme.” The government will be allocating 93 million carbon units, primarily to the forestry and industrial sectors, during the first compliance period (CP1). Yet when transport enters into the scheme in two years time the the total demand from included sectors over CP1 is only 61 units. Meaning that the government is massively over allocating,

with the result that the market price for carbon will be low, and there will be little pressure on polluters to reduce emissions. Meanwhile, that extra 40 million units - almost a year’s net emissions - will be sold on the international market, worsening [New Zealand’s] net position and funnelling over $800 million into the pockets of favoured industries

When New Zealand ratified the Kyoto Protocol in 2002 it was expected to become a carbon creditor nation thanks to the increase in forestry since 1990, creating “carbon sinks” which would generate units additional to the country’s initial allocation. However 2005 forecasts showed New Zealand more likely to be in a carbon deficit, requiring credits from other countries. Under the Emissions Trading Scheme however, it appears that a few industries will benefit financially, without pollution being reduced.

Today also begins the implementation of the Government’s biofuels sales obligation policy; 0.5% of the combined petrol and diesel sold by fuel companies over the next year now has to be biofuel, making (slightly) more of the country’s energy renewable. However, Chevron New Zealand, which operates Caltex petrol stations, says it can’t start building the infrastructure needed to import the fuels until the policy is guaranteed to remain in the future. The National Party has stated it will scrap the policy if it’s elected in next months election.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
2 Stars
You are absolutely right. Carbon Credits is nothing more than the old Barter scheme, and New Zealand bought into the myth. I believe the idea was dreamed up in the now defunked Enron as a way to make money.
The solution is simple for any country that is an industrial operator by law cannot function unless preventative measures are put in place to lower the junk into the atmosphere. Sure there is climate change and no doubt in the last 100 years we have as mankind contributed to this natural phenomenon.
Next some-one will dream up the idea of the average human and how much they breathe in or out and we will e taxed for that. Carbon Credit system is just big money for big business that benefits no-one and cripples eventually a country and its’ people.
2 Stars
Vijay
Kota, India
Very informative Marie
”However 2005 forecasts showed New Zealand more likely to be in a carbon deficit, requiring credits from other countries. Under the Emissions Trading Scheme however, it appears that a few industries will benefit financially, without pollution being reduced.”
2 Stars
Yes New Zealand would be in deficit it seems, buying credits from other countries. Thats not good we are not the most wealthy of Nations. Also it has to start at the core, industries know how to clean up their act, just the will to do so, if not make it law and abolish Carbon Credits.
Add your Comment